Yes they can. And in fact they do it all the time. I have met many people who want to paint but are frightened of making mistakes: drawing or painting something that looks wrong. There is a myth that good artists get it right the first time. There is also a myth that artists don’t cheat but more on that in another blog!
If you watch the BBC One production Fake or Fortune you will know how often a painting belonging to a famous artist shows many attempts to “get it right” under layers of paint.
The correct word is Pentimento which refers to a change made in a painting though not to a complete alteration to a different subject. It doesn’t include “fixing” up your father’s unfinished paintings for sale after he died as apparently done by some of John Constable’s children.
And definitely doesn’t refer to painting a new painting over an old one which goes on all the time especially if you are poor! I have one painting produced on an expensive linen board which has two other paintings underneath!! Not that I’m a poor artist starving in a garret, but I hate to waste a good linen board.
Here is a famous example of pentimento as revealed by an x-ray of Van Eyck's painting "Arnolfini Wedding Portrait". We can see that Van Eyck changed the position of the hands.
There is a very good article on pentimenti on Wikipedia
But why do artists change their minds? One reason is that it isn’t easy to get the exact image an artist will have in their mind. Photographers take numerous shots to get one perfect photo. A painter has to re-sketch or repaint. You start with an idea and an image of that idea in what I call the MindStudio. But sometimes (often with me) when you start to paint things don’t look right so they have to be changed.
Also many painters aren’t necessarily good drawers. Van Gogh is a notable example as is our very own Sidney Nolan. So they have to have a “couple” of goes to get it right. Here are the practice sketches done by Van Gogh showing many attempts to draw people sitting on a chair. Look at the strange feet on the largest figure.
And look at these drawings of Sidney Nolan who became one of Australia's most famous artists but not for his drawing ability. The first shows his struggle with the shape of a horse (arguably the most difficult animal to draw).
It was known that Nolan had trouble drawing heads. This sketch says it all!! A headless artist!
Personally I find hands very difficult and will put them in pockets and behind backs!!
Here are a couple of paintings I have changed. The first with respect to the colours being used.
Autumn among the rooftops was originally Viewpoints
And to give you a laugh. My painting of the Royal Botanic Gardens was donated for a raffle at the nursing home where I taught painting-covered in quilled objects! Quilling refers to making objects from strips of paper that are rolled, shaped and glued together to create decorative designs.
The PaintAlong videos I'm producing of Painting the Town show how many changes I make to keep improving the composition. I've moved the river three times, constantly altered the planned positions of the cottages and I haven't started on the people!
In this early plan you can see the planned positions of the cottages. And this is what the painting looks like at the moment.
You can see the river is now in the middle of the painting fading away beyond the town. Its old course has become a road. Study the painting to spot the changes in my thinking.